﻿<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?><Search><pages Count="24"><page Index="1"><![CDATA[DELLA








                                                                ARS F
            FUTUR                             E W                                           OR
            FUTURE WARS FOR



            THE DOMIN                                                A      TION
            THE DOMINATION



            OF RAR                               E E            AR            THS
            OF RARE EARTHS




                                                  W
            AND RA
            AND RAW



                            TER
            MA                                  IALS:
            MATERIALS:





            A S             tr      a    t  egic A                       nal           ys        i  s
            A Strategic Analysis]]></page><page Index="2"><![CDATA[Immage create with A.I.




           2                                                                                           3-2025]]></page><page Index="3"><![CDATA[PAOLO CAPPELLI


                                             Future                                                             SPECIAL


               Rare earths
               are                           Wars for the

               a cornerstone

               of modern                     Domination of
               military

               capabilities.                 Rare Earths
               Their control

               not only                      and Raw
               supports

               the                           Materials:

               development
               of high-tech                  A Strategic

               consumer
               products,                     Analysis

               but also
               provides a

               significant

               military
               advantage,                    T        The 21st century is witnessing a dramatic increase in demand
                                                      for rare earth elements (REE) and essential raw materials,
               making                                 driven by rapid technological advances, the shift to renewable
                                                      energy and growing military needs. Rare earths and specific
               them critical                 commodities such as cobalt, lithium and nickel have become critical to
               to national                   the global economy, as they are essential for the production of high-tech
                                             equipment, electric vehicles, renewable energy systems and military
               defense                       hardware.  This  dependence  has  increased  the  strategic  importance
                                             of these resources,  making control  of their  supply  chains a national
               strategies.                   security imperative for many countries. While attention to rare earths
                                             and commodities often focuses on their role in civil industries, their
                                             importance to military applications cannot be underestimated. REEs are
                                             essential for the production of advanced weapons, radar systems, missile
                                             guidance systems and stealth technologies, giving nations with secure
                                             access to these materials a significant advantage in modern warfare. As
                                             demand grows and supply remains concentrated in a few regions, future
                                             conflicts over these resources appear increasingly likely. This analysis
                                             explores the geopolitical landscape of REEs and critical commodities,
                                             looking at current and future players, military applications of these
                                             materials and potential conflict scenarios. It also examines strategies that
                                             could mitigate the risks of wars for control of these vital resources.


            Rivista del Ministero della Difesa                                                                3]]></page><page Index="4"><![CDATA[REEs are made up of 17 chemically similar elements,  •   Missile  guidance  systems:  Neodymium  and
            including  lanthanides   such   as  neodymium,       dysprosium are used in the powerful magnets
            dysprosium and praseodymium, as well as scandium     found in missile guidance systems, which require
            and yttrium. Despite their relative abundance in     precision and reliability in combat scenarios.
            the Earth’s crust, these elements are rarely found  •   Stealth technology: radar-absorbing materials
            in concentrated and  economically  viable  deposits,   used in stealth aircraft and ships often contain
            making their extraction complex and expensive.       rare earth elements to avoid enemy detection.
            As a result, the production and refining of REEs is  •   Night vision goggles: Yttrium is used in night
            concentrated in a few key regions, notably China,    vision goggles, which are essential for modern
            which controls most of the world’s supply. REEs have   military operations.
            many civil applications, including                •   Radar  and sonar  systems:  Advanced  radar
            •   Renewable energy, as they are essential in the   and sonar systems, essential for early warning
                production of wind turbines, electric vehicle    defence  systems and  naval  operations,  have
                motors and energy storage systems. As the global   powerful magnets and sensors that use REEs.
                shift to renewable energy accelerates, demand  •   Jet engines: Their high temperature tolerance
                for these materials will increase.               makes  them  essential  in the  production  of jet
            •   Consumer electronics, where they are essential   engines used in combat aircraft and other military
                for  modern  electronics,  including  smartphones,   platforms.
                laptops  and  televisions,  which  rely  on  their  REEs are therefore a cornerstone of modern military
                magnetic, conductive and luminescent properties.  capabilities. Their control not only supports the
            On the other hand, REEs are widely used to support  development  of  high-tech consumer products,  but
            advanced  military  technologies,  particularly  in the  also provides a significant military advantage, making
            production  of  high-performance  defence  systems.  them critical to national defence strategies.
            Some of the most important military applications  In addition, other raw materials such as cobalt,
            include:                                          lithium and nickel have become essential resources


           4                                                                                           3-2025]]></page><page Index="5"><![CDATA[for modern technologies. These  is deeply rooted in its long-term economic and
                           materials  are  critical  for  the  geopolitical strategy. As the world’s largest producer
                           production of lithium-ion batteries  and  refiner, it  has  developed  a dominant  position
                           used in electric vehicles, renewable  that gives it considerable influence in global markets,
                           energy   storage   systems   and   particularly in the technology and defence sectors. It
                           portable electronic devices. The  is the result of state initiatives that have systematically
                           strategic  importance  of   these  increased China’s capacity to extract, process and
                           materials has increased in recent  export these vital materials.
                           years, particularly due to military  At the heart of China’s strategy is state investment. The
                           applications such as               Chinese government has long recognised the strategic
                           •   military     drones       for  importance of REEs, not only for civil industries but
                              reconnaissance,    surveillance  also  for military applications.  As a  result, Beijing
                              and targeted attacks;           has invested considerable resources in developing
                           •   portable military equipment,  domestic  mining  and refining industries.  Generous
                              from     communications     to  subsidies and a favourable regulatory environment
                              navigation systems;             have enabled Chinese companies to overcome
                           •   military  electric vehicles,  which  global competition and secure control of most of
                              reduce  the carbon  footprint  the  world’s  REEs  production  and  processing,  even
                              of armed forces and improve  beyond  its borders,  through strategic  acquisitions
                              battlefield logistics, but require  and investments in other countries.
                              large quantities of lithium, cobalt  China’s overseas expansion has also been crucial to
                              and nickel for their batteries;  maintaining its dominance: it has invested heavily
                           •   energy  storage  for  military  in mining in Africa, Latin America and Central Asia,
                              bases in remote or hostile  securing  access  to  key  raw materials  beyond  its
                              environments, which is safe  borders. This international expansion has secured the
                              and reliable but dependent on  supply chains that feed China’s domestic industries,
                              lithium and cobalt.             ensuring a steady flow of the raw materials needed
                           •   Their  military   applications  to support technological and military advances. In
                              highlight    their    growing   addition, investment has tied resource-rich countries
                              importance in both conventional  closely  to  China,  often  making them  dependent  on
                              and asymmetric warfare, making  Chinese infrastructure and financing, and creating
                              control of their supply chains  long-term debt.
                              a strategic priority for many  In addition to economic expansion, China has used its
                                  nations.                    control of REEs as a geopolitical tool. One of the most
                                                              notable examples came in 2010, when it imposed a
                                                              de facto embargo on rare earth shipments to Japan
            THE CURRENT GLOBAL LANDSCAPE: ACTORS  during a territorial dispute over the Senkaku Islands.
            IN  THE  BATTLE  FOR  REES  AND  CRITICAL  This move not only highlighted China’s willingness
            MATERIALS                                         to use REEs as a weapon in geopolitical disputes, but
                                                              also underlined the vulnerability of countries heavily
            China’s Strategic Approac                         dependent on Chinese imports. By exploiting its near
            China’s success in the REEs sector is the result of  monopoly, China can pressure other nations to align
            long-term strategic initiatives. Through investment  themselves with its political and strategic interests.
            and government subsidies, China has systematically  As demand for REEs continues to grow with the
            developed mining and refining capacity, securing its  development of renewable energy technologies,
            position as a major producer and refiner. The country  electric vehicles and high-tech industries, China’s
            has also expanded its global presence through  strategic approach puts it in a powerful position.
            investments in Africa, Latin America and Central  For countries  such as the United States,  Japan and
            Asia, securing access to key commodities beyond  members of the European Union, China’s dominance
            its borders. China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI)  in REEs poses a significant strategic challenge. These
            has further cemented its dominance by connecting  are nations that rely heavily on Chinese supplies
            resource-rich countries to Chinese infrastructure and  to fuel their technological  advances, making them
            creating dependencies on its supply chains.       vulnerable to supply disruptions in the event of
            China is the undisputed leader in REEs production and  geopolitical tensions. As a result, China’s strategic
            refining, controlling around 60% of global production  approach not only secures its technological and
            and over 80% of refining capacity.                military future, but also gives it considerable influence
            China’s approach to REEs and critical commodities  in global markets and international relations.


            Informazioni della Difesa                                                                         5]]></page><page Index="6"><![CDATA[global production
            rare earth element

            115.820.000


            TONS






                       Canada                                                            Groenlandia


                       0,83 Mln
                       tons                                                              0,89 Mln
                                                                                         tons


                                 USA


                                 1,8 Mln
                                 tons
                                                       TANZANIA
                                                       0,8%
                                                       SUDAFRICA
                GROENLANDIA                            0,7%
                       1,3%
                                                       AUSTRALIA
                     RUSSIA                            3,5%
                      10,3%
                                                        ALTRI PAESI
                  CANADA                                0,3%
                     0,7%
                      USA
                      1,6%
                    BRASILE          WORLD                      CINA
                       18,1%       ESTRAZIONE           CINA    VIETNAM
                                   RARE EARTH           37,9%   INDIA
                                    MONDIALE
                                                                BRASILE
                                     MINING
                                   TERRE RARE                   USA                          Brasile
                                                                CANADA
                                                                RUSSIA
                                                                GROENLANDIA
                                                                TANZANIA
                     INDIA                                      SUDAFRICA                    21 Mln
                      5,9%                                      AUSTRALIA
                                                                                             tons
                                                                ALTRI PAESI
                   VIETNAM
                      18,9%
                         RARE EARTH                         WHAT ARE RARE EARTH ELEMENT
                              17                        •   They are not true earths and they are not that
                                                           rare, but they are fundamental metals for many
                      chemical elements                    modern technologies.
                                                        •   They are used in consumer electronics, optical
                                                           fibers, lasers, sensors, displays, catalysts,
              •  Lantalio (La)     •  Terbio (Tb)          superconductors, permanent magnets, and in
              •  Cerio (Ce)        •  Disprosio (Dy)       components of hybrid and electric cars.
              •  Praseodomio       •  Olmio (Ho)        •   Their extraction is very polluting: for every ton
               (Pr)                •  Erbio (Er)           of rare earths, up to 2,000 tons of toxic waste
              •  Neodimio (Nd)     •  Tulio (Tm)           are produced.
              •  Promezio (Pm)     •  Itterbio (Yb)     •   Recycling rare earths is very difficult: in
              •  Samario (Sm)      •  Lutezio (Lu)         electronic devices they are found in minimal
              •  Europio (Eu)      •  Scandio (Sc)         quantities (mg), difficult to recover.
              •  Gadolino (Gd)     •  Ittrio (Y)        •   A recycling chain would require large
                                                           investments and a lot of time.



           6                                                                                           3-2025]]></page><page Index="7"><![CDATA[Russia


                                                            12 Mln
                                                            tons
                                                                                               Cina

                                                                                               44 Mln
                                                                                               tons

                                                                                               ~100%
                                                                                               control
                                                                                               of heavy
                                                                                               rare earth
                                                                                               processing


                                                                                          Vietnam


                                                                                          22 Mln
                                                                                          tons
                                                   India


                                                   6,9 Mln
                                                   tons
                                         Tanzania

            Sudafrica                    0,89 Mln                  Australia

                                         tons
            0,79 Mln                                               4 Mln
            tons
                                                                   tons


                       CHINA'S DOMINANCE                                   THE SITUATION
                                                                     IN EUROPE AND THE USA
             •   China controls about 70% of all global
                 extraction (270,000 tons out of 390,000      •   USA: The Mountain Pass mine in
                 in 2024).                                        California mines light rare earths, not
             •   It controls the processing of almost 100%        heavy ones. It has limited capacity.
                 of heavy rare earths, the most difficult to   •   Europe: It has reserves (mainly in
                 refine and most strategic.                       Scandinavia and Serbia), but activating
             •   On April 4, 2024, Beijing imposed                new mines requires decades and major
                 export restrictions on 7 heavy rare              environmental and political choices.
                 earths: samarium, gadolinium, terbium,       •   Many companies operate with minimal
                 dysprosium, lutetium, scandium, and              stocks to save money, which increases
                 yttrium. A special license is required,          the risk in the event of a prolonged
                 which is granted slowly, effectively             embargo.
                 blocking exports.




            Informazioni della Difesa                                                                         7]]></page><page Index="8"><![CDATA[Stati Uniti: giocare a nascondino                 energy, electric vehicle production and advanced
            The United States, once the world’s leading producer  manufacturing  rely  heavily  on  these  materials,  but
            of REEs, has been playing catch-up in recent years.  the region has no significant domestic production. As
            The closure of its main rare earth mine, Mountain  a result, the EU has taken several steps to reduce its
            Pass, in the early 2000s left the US dependent on  dependence on external sources, particularly China,
            imports, particularly from China, to meet demand  and to ensure a more stable supply of critical materials.
            for these critical materials. In recent years, however,  One of the EU’s key strategies is the creation of the
            the US government and industry have increasingly  European Raw Materials Alliance (ERMA). Launched
            recognised the strategic risks posed by this  in 2020, ERMA aims to strengthen the European
            dependence, particularly given China’s dominance in  supply chain for critical materials by supporting new
            the sector and the key role that REEs play in defence  mining projects in Europe and abroad, promoting
            technologies and renewable energy.                recycling  initiatives  and  developing  partnerships
            One of the most significant initiatives taken by the US  with  resource-rich  countries  such  as  Canada  and
            was the reopening of the Mountain Pass mine in 2017.  Australia.  ERMA  brings together  key  stakeholders
            However, the US continues to send raw minerals to
            China for refining, highlighting the continued US
            reliance on Chinese processing capacity, despite
            significant investment to expand domestic refining
            capacity, and recognising that reliance on foreign
            sources for these materials poses a national security
            risk.  The  United  States  faces  significant  challenges
            in achieving full independence from China. This
            dependence has led to increased government
            support,  with  the  Pentagon  funding  rare  earth
            projects to ensure access to critical materials needed
            for military technologies such as stealth and missile
            guidance systems, which are even more important in
            times of geopolitical tension.
            In  addition  to domestic  initiatives,  the  US has
            turned  to  international  partnerships  to  diversify  its
            supply chains. The US is working with allies such as
            Australia and Canada to secure alternative sources
            of REEs and critical raw materials. The aim of these
            partnerships  is  to  reduce  dependence  on  Chinese
            imports by drawing on the resources of trusted allies,
            thereby creating a more resilient supply chain that
            is less vulnerable to potential disruptions caused by
            geopolitical conflict or trade disputes.
            Despite these efforts, significant challenges remain.
            Developing a fully independent REEs supply chain  from industry, academia and government to create
            is a complex  and time-consuming  process. The  a more resilient  and sustainable  critical materials
            United States does not yet have the refining capacity  supply chain.
            to process REEs domestically, which means it will  Beyond mining, the EU has made sustainability
            continue  to  rely  on Chinese  infrastructure  for the  a cornerstone of its strategy. Recognising the
            foreseeable  future.  In  addition,  the  global  nature  of  environmental and political challenges associated
            rare earth supply chains makes it difficult  for any  with traditional mining, it has invested in technologies
            nation  to achieve  complete self-sufficiency.  Until  to recycle REEs and other critical materials from
            the US is able to address these issues, it will remain  end-of-life products such as electric vehicle batteries
            vulnerable to supply disruptions, particularly in the  and wind turbines. By creating a circular economy
            event of heightened tensions with China.          around these materials, the EU hopes to reduce its
                                                              dependence on primary imports while addressing
            L'Unione     Europea:     obiettivi   ambiziosi,  concerns about the environmental impact of mining
            vulnerabilità strategiche                         and resources. This approach not only helps to
            The European Union, like the United States, faces  ensure  a more sustainable  supply  of  materials,  but

            significant strategic vulnerabilities due to its  is also in line with the EU’s wider environmental and
            dependence on imports of REEs and other critical raw  climate goals.
            materials. Europe’s ambitious targets for renewable  International  cooperation  has  also  been  a  key


           8                                                                                           3-2025]]></page><page Index="9"><![CDATA[element of Europe’s strategy to secure the supply of  and underdeveloped infrastructure.
            critical  materials.  The EU  has  sought  to strengthen
            diplomatic and economic  ties with countries that  The  Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) stands
            have  significant  reserves  of  REEs and  other  critical  out as the world’s largest producer of cobalt, a key
            materials. In particular, Europe has focused on  component in the production of lithium-ion batteries
            building  relationships  with  resource-rich  nations  used in electric vehicles and renewable energy storage
            such  as  Australia,  Canada  and  several  African  systems, making the DRC a key player in the global
            countries. These partnerships aim to ensure stable  transition  to  clean  energy.  However,  the  country’s
            and diversified supply chains that are less vulnerable  mining  industry  faces  a  number  of  challenges,
            to geopolitical disruptions.                      including political instability and corruption, which
            Despite these efforts, Europe’s import dependence  severely limit its ability to maximise its potential.
            remains a significant vulnerability. Europe still imports  Artisanal mining, which includes small-scale and
            the vast majority of the REEs and key commodities it  often informal mining activities, is widespread in the
            uses from China, making the region highly vulnerable  DRC and raises concerns about human rights abuses,
                                                              including child labour. Despite these challenges, the
                                                              DRC remains a key player due to the huge volume of
                                                              its cobalt production and is a major target for foreign
                                                              investment, particularly from China.

                                                              South Africa is another key player in the African
                                                              mining  landscape,  with  significant  reserves  of  REEs
                                                              and other critical materials. However, like the DRC,
                                                              South Africa’s mining industry has faced its own
                                                              challenges. Labour disputes, political tensions and
                                                              a lack of modern infrastructure have hampered the
                                                              country’s ability to exploit its resource wealth. South
                                                              Africa’s REEs industry has the potential to make a
                                                              significant contribution to the global supply  chain,
                                                              but  requires  further investment  and modernisation
                                                              to compete with global players such as China and
                                                              Australia. However, the country remains strategically
                                                              important due to its reserves and established mining
                                                              infrastructure.

                                                              Madagascar, with its rich deposits of minerals such as
                                                              graphite and REEs, has also emerged as a key player
                                                              in the global supply of critical materials. However, like
                                                              many African countries, it faces significant challenges
                                                              related to political instability and underdevelopment.
            to supply disruptions. In a scenario where geopolitical  Chinese investment in Madagascar’s mining sector
            tensions escalate or China imposes export restrictions,  has increased significantly in recent years, as China
            Europe could face serious shortages of the materials  seeks to secure access to the island’s rare earth
            needed to support the transition to renewable energy  deposits.  This  dynamic  has  raised  concerns  about
            and advanced manufacturing.                       the possibility of over-reliance on Chinese investment
                                                              and control over Madagascar’s resources.
            Africa: Resource-rich but politically unstable
            Africa has long been recognised as a key player in the  The geopolitical importance of Africa in the global
            global supply of REEs and critical raw materials. Major  scramble for REEs and essential commodities
            African countries have rich deposits of materials such  is undeniable. However, the region’s political
            as cobalt, lithium and tantalum, which are essential for  fragility,  economic  challenges  and  dependence  on
            modern technology, from electric vehicles to military  foreign investment, particularly from China, raise
            applications. Key African players in this field include  significant concerns about its ability to capitalise
            the Democratic Republic of Congo, South Africa and  on its resource wealth. As global demand for these
            Madagascar,  each of which has significant  reserves  materials continues to grow, African countries will
            of critical materials. However, despite its wealth of  need to address these challenges in order to position
            resources,  Africa’s  ability  to  maximise  its  potential  themselves as reliable and stable suppliers in the
            is often hampered by political instability, corruption  global supply chain and still make a reasonable profit.


            Informazioni della Difesa                                                                         9]]></page><page Index="10"><![CDATA[Molybdenum mining
                         Ilmenite (Ti) mining
                       Bluejay Mining GreenRoc Mining Greenland Resources REE exploration/mining  Leading Edge Materials  NEW ROADMAP
                              Graphite mining
                                                                 Mining/processing of REE
 Third, a strengthened ecosystem in the fuel cell and electrolyser industry is a key component of the proposed   Tanbreez  Grängesberg Exploration  FOR A RAW
 actions. This will lead to measurable impact in terms of cost reduction due to reduced costs in sourcing and   Exploration/mining of apatite and REE  MATERIALS
 production and improved synergies that drive the R&D efforts in this sector. Staying ahead of the competition   Superior Graphite  VALUE CHAIN
                                                                 Production of battery-grade graphite
 is crucial in this emerging sector.                                                  ERMA 2023
                   REETec
 The alternative energy storage & conversion will benefit hugely from R&D-related actions that will translate   REO refining  Nordic Mining
                                   Rutile (Ti) and garnet mining
 into potentially significant GWh to TWh-scale energy storage capacities to cover the seasonal volatility of re-  REE Minerals  NanoPow  SSAB/Neometals
 newable energies and ensure strategic energy security. Decisive and timely actions in this sector have the po-  REE mining  Battery anode material production  Vanadium recovery from steel scrap  FMG
                                                                                                     Battery materials
                                                                                                     (CAM and pCAM)
 tential to establish Europe as a world leader in the field. Advanced materials and storage and conversion solu-  Norsk Mineral  Mineral Commodities  Lithium mining and refining  Akku Minerals
                                                                                    Keliber
                          REE mining
                                            Graphite mining
 tions can furthermore lead to double-digit energy savings in the clean energy sector.  Norge Mineraler  Graphite mining
         Mining of phosphates, titanium and vanadium deposits
 While we acknowledge that the increased use of wind energy is central to the European climate goals, questions
 regarding the raw materials related to wind power have been covered in previous work by ERMA in the Cluster
 1 Action Plan on Rare Earth Magnets and Motors. A summary of the work can be found at the end of this Action
                                Vacuumschmelze
 Plan.                          REE magnet production

 Most ERMA stakeholders identified permitting as one of the most crucial bottlenecks in the development of   Pure Battery Technologies  NeoPerformance Materials
                                  Battery materials
                                                                                          REE magnet production value chain
 domestic resources and processing capacity. The uncertainty associated with the timing and outcomes of the
                                 Saxore Bergbau
 permitting process introduces a very high level of risk for potential investors, thus preventing many otherwise   Tin, indium, zinc and iron mining
 viable projects from being implemented. Many European countries have no time limits for environmental permit   Hypromag  Adianano
 handling, and different aspects of permit applications are often handled by different authorities that work inde-  REO production from  Battery anode material production
      recycled magnets
 pendently. While it is absolutely crucial that that public be given the opportunity to scrutinize permit applications   Mkango Resources
                                                                               REE mining and processing
 and appeal permit decisions, it is equally crucial that these processes be streamlined. The Critical Raw Materials   Orion Engineered Carbons
 Act’s intention to streamline and set a strict timeframe for permitting, in line with the recommendations made   Acetylene black production  Volt Resources
 by the ERMA community, is a very welcome positive development.                                   Graphite mining
                                                                              European Lithium
                                                                              Lithium mining
 ERMA Investment pipeline                                                                         Mures Magnesium
            Aurora Lithium
            Lithium mining                                                                        Magnesium recovery
                                                                                                  from waste
 To increase Europe’s strategic autonomy in Materials for Energy Storage and Conversion, the EU will need to   Savannah Resources  Verde Magnesium
            Lithium mining
                                                                                                  Magnesium metal production
 address the entire value chain. This involves the boosting of exploration, mining, separation, and processing and
 the building of a circular economy around materials for energy storage and conversion by advancing ecodesign   Altilium Metal
                                                                                                  Recycling of Li-ion batteries
 requirements, waste collection, recycling activities. Today, there is limited primary production within the EU and
 for some materials related to energy storage, the EU relies almost entirely on imports. There is also a significant   EULiBOR
 lack of recycling facilities across Europe which, by 2050, could potentially become the main source for supplying   Eramet  Lithium and borates mining
                                                Recycling of
 an increasing demand for critical raw materials.  Li-ion batteries                             Rio Tinto
                                   Carester     Eramet                                          Lithium and borates mining
                              REO production from  Ni-Co sulfate refinery
 As of May 2023, ERMA has identified over 50 investment cases targeting materials for energy storage and   recycled magnets  and pCAM  Magneti  Arcore
 conversion across Europe and beyond and a total investment need exceeding EUR 15 billion (Figure 1). If these   REE magnet manufacturing  Eramet  Ljubljana  Lithium and borates mining
                               MagREESource
                                                                         REE magnet
                                                Geothermal lithium
 projects were realised, a significant percentage amount for some materials could be sourced from the EU by   and recycling  production  production  Magnesium For Europe
                                                                                                Magnesium metal production
 2030, that is, significantly higher than today and, for some materials, even higher than the targets set in the   Rafaella Resources  Atlantic Copper  Sudmine
                                                Tantalum and
 Critical Raw Materials Act. This is illustrated in Figure 2, where global and EU demand and production data for   Tungsten mining  Cu, Zn, Pb and Ag mining and refining  niobium mining  TREEE
 2020 are compared with forecasted global and EU demand data for 2030 for a selected group of critical and   Mining Hill’s  Cobre Las Cruces  Sanou Koura  Recovery of metals from WEEE
                                                Recovery of metals
 strategic materials.  Tungsten mining  Recovery of metals from WEEE  from WEEE  Circular Materials  Torngat
                                                                    Metal recycling
                                                                                                 REE mining
                        EQ Resources
                        Tungsten mining                                                          Shin Etsu
                                                                                          REE magnets, full process
       Geographic distribution of  current  and potential raw  materials  projects  identified
        Figure 1. Geographic distribution of current and potential raw materials projects identified through the ERMA investment
       through the ERMA investment pipeline. Some projects are not shown on this map for        Albemarle
        pipeline. Some projects are not shown on this map due to confidentiality, but are included in the ERMA supply data
       confidentiality reasons but are included in the ERMA supply data.              Lithium hydroxide production plant
 12     reported in this document and in the high-level ERMA investment needs shown in Figures 2 and 4.  3-2025
          10]]></page><page Index="11"><![CDATA[DISTRIBUTION OF REE DEPOSITS IN AFRICA








                                                                                       REE Mineral Deposit

                                                                                       REE Rich Country


                                                                                       Non-REE Rich Country










































                Source: U.S. Geological Survey






















            Informazioni della Difesa                                                                         11]]></page><page Index="12"><![CDATA[POTENTIAL FUTURE PLAYERS IN THE BATTLE  interests in REEs. As a major military power, it relies
            FOR REES AND COMMODITIE                           on advanced technologies that require REEs, such
                                                              as missile guidance systems, radar systems and jet
            Russia: an emerging player??                      engines. These materials are critical to maintaining
            While not a dominant player in the REEs market,  the technological edge of Russia’s military-industrial
            Russia has vast reserves of critical minerals, including  complex, especially as the country seeks to modernise
            cobalt and lithium. As global demand for these  its armed forces and expand its capabilities in both
            materials continues to grow, Russia’s strategic interest  conventional and asymmetric warfare. Ensuring
            in exploiting its natural resource wealth is becoming  access to a stable supply of REEs is therefore a key
            increasingly clear. Russia’s geopolitical position,  component of Russia’s national defence strategy.
            combined with its historical use of energy resources  Geopolitical leverage is another factor underpinning
            as a foreign policy tool, suggests that it may adopt a  Russia’s interest in REEs and essential commodities.
            similar approach to REEs and critical minerals in the  The country has a long history of using its energy
            future.                                           resources, particularly oil and natural gas, as foreign
            One of Russia’s key strategic interests is to secure its  policy tools. For example, it has used its control
            technological  independence. In recent years, it has  over gas supplies to Europe as a means of exerting
            come under severe pressure from Western sanctions,  pressure on neighbouring countries and influencing
            which have affected its economy and limited its access  political outcomes. It is conceivable that Russia could
            to foreign technology. As a result, it has expressed a  adopt a similar approach to REEs, especially as global
            desire to reduce its reliance on foreign technology  demand  for  these  materials  continues  to  grow.  By
            and become more self-sufficient in critical sectors.  leveraging its resource wealth, Russia could gain
            Securing domestic sources of REEs and critical raw  greater influence in global markets and increase its
            materials is essential to achieving this goal, as these  bargaining power in international relations.
            materials are essential to the production of advanced  Russia’s  growing  ties  with China  are  also  important
            technologies,  including  military  hardware  and  in this context. As China continues to dominate the
            consumer electronics.                             global REEs market, it may seek to secure additional
            Russia’s military applications also drive its strategic  sources  of  REEs from  Russia.  This  dynamic  could


          12                                                                                           3-2025]]></page><page Index="13"><![CDATA[further  consolidate  control  over these  critical  military capabilities, India is positioning itself as a key
            materials, giving both Russia and China significant  player in the global competition for REEs and critical
            influence over global supply chains. Furthermore,  materials.
            as Western nations seek to reduce their dependence
            on Chinese imports, Russia could position itself as an  Latin America: The Lithium Triangle
            alternative  supplier,  potentially using its  resources  Latin  America,  particularly  the  countries  of  Chile,
            as a geopolitical tool in its dealings with Europe and  Argentina and Bolivia, is home to some of the world’s
            Asia.                                             largest lithium reserves. This region, known as the
                                                              ‘Lithium Triangle’, is becoming increasingly important
            India: a rising technological power               as  the world  moves  towards electric  vehicles  and
            As a fast-growing  technological power,  India is  renewable energy storage.
            becoming  an  increasingly  important  player  in  the  The Lithium Triangle is home to some of the world’s
            global market for REEs and key commodities. With  largest reserves of the metal, which is critical for the
            its booming technology sector, ambitious renewable  production of batteries that are essential for electric
            energy targets and growing military capabilities, India  vehicles, renewable energy storage systems and
            has  recognised  the  need  to  ensure  a  stable  supply  portable electronics. As global demand for electric
            of these vital resources. Although India has some  vehicles and clean energy technologies has increased,
            domestic reserves of REEs, its mining and refining  the strategic importance of the lithium triangle
            capacity is still underdeveloped, and the country  has grown significantly, particularly as the shift to
            relies on imports to meet much of its needs. However,  renewable energy and the electrification of transport
            the Indian government has launched several strategic  create unprecedented demand. As countries around
            initiatives to reduce this dependency and strengthen  the world seek to phase out fossil fuels, demand has
            its position in the global supply chain.          skyrocketed, making reserves in the lithium triangle a
            One of the most important is the development of a  critical component of the global supply chain.
            domestic REEs industry. The Indian government has  Both China and Western countries have expressed
            announced its intention to invest in domestic mining  strong interest in securing access to the lithium
            and processing facilities in order to become more  triangle’s reserves. Chinese companies have already
            self-sufficient in the production of critical materials.  made significant investments in mining activities in
            India’s defence sector, particularly its missile and  the region to secure a stable supply of the material
            radar systems, relies heavily on REEs, making the  for their fast-growing electric vehicle and renewable
            development of a domestic supply chain a national  energy sectors. At the same time, Western countries,
            security priority.                                particularly the US and Europe, are seeking to
            In addition to domestic initiatives, India has sought  establish partnerships with the Triangle countries
            to strengthen partnerships with key allies to secure  to reduce their dependence on Chinese imports and
            access to REEs and critical raw materials. Australia, in  secure a diversified supply.
            particular, has emerged as a key partner in this regard.  The potential conflict over control of these resources
            As one of the world’s leading producers of REEs, it has  underlines the geopolitical importance of the
            become an important source of critical materials for  lithium  triangle. As  global competition  intensifies,
            India’s growing technology and defence industries.  the region could become a battleground for
            By working with Australia and other resource-rich  influence between major powers. However, political
            nations, India aims to diversify its supply chains and  instability in countries such as Bolivia and Argentina,
            reduce its dependence on China, which, as noted  superimposed on economic challenges, could further
            above, currently dominates the global REEs market.  complicate efforts to secure access to the region’s
            India’s military modernisation efforts are closely  reserves.  In addition,  concerns  over environmental
            linked  to  its  strategic  initiatives  in  the  REEs  sector.  degradation and the rights of indigenous communities
            As India seeks to develop advanced defence  have heightened regional tensions, adding another
            technologies and modernise its military capabilities,  layer of complexity to the global competition for the
            securing  a  steady  supply  has  become  increasingly  precious metal.
            important.                                        The strategic importance of the Lithium Triangle will
            Finally, India’s broader geopolitical position in the  continue to grow in the coming decades due to its
            Indo-Pacific region increases its strategic importance  vast reserves and increasing global demand. Chile,
            in the global competition  for REEs and  critical raw  Argentina and Bolivia will play a key role in shaping
            materials. As an emerging power in the region, India  the future of the global lithium supply chain. However,
            is well positioned to play a key role in shaping the  the region’s political instability, economic challenges
            future of the global supply chain for these materials.  and environmental concerns must be addressed to
            By investing in domestic production, strengthening  ensure a stable and sustainable supply of these vital
            international partnerships and modernising its  materials.


            Informazioni della Difesa                                                                         13]]></page><page Index="14"><![CDATA[GEOPOLITICAL RISKS AND FUTURE CONFLICT  to hybrid car batteries. Although the embargo was
            SCENARIOS                                         short-lived, it highlighted the vulnerability of countries
                                                              heavily dependent on Chinese supplies of REEs.
            As demand for REEs and essential commodities  If China were to impose similar restrictions on rare
            continues to grow, competition for control of these  earth exports today, the consequences could be
            resources is likely to intensify.                 even more severe, given the growing global demand
            One of the immediate risks is the rise of resource  for  these  materials.  The United  States,  Japan  and
            nationalism, where countries with significant reserves  the European Union, all of which rely on rare earth
            of REEs and key commodities adopt policies to restrict  imports for their defence and technology industries,
            exports in order to protect their domestic industries.  would face significant disruption. The renewable
            Such actions could lead to trade wars and significant  energy,  electric  vehicle  and consumer  electronics
            disruptions to global supply chains.              industries would be particularly affected, as REEs are
                                                              critical to the production of wind turbines, electric
            Scenario 1: China imposes restrictions to REEs  motors and various high-tech components.
            exportse                                          In response, affected countries could respond with
            In 2010, the world witnessed a stark demonstration of  trade measures such as tariffs or export restrictions
            China’s willingness to use its dominance in REEs for  on other goods, raising tensions and potentially
            geopolitical advantage. During a territorial dispute  leading to a wider trade war. In addition, countries
            with Japan over the Senkaku Islands, China imposed  could accelerate efforts to develop alternative supply
            an unofficial embargo on rare earth exports to Japan.  chains, investing heavily in domestic mining and
            The move sent shockwaves through industries  refining capacity or seeking new sources of REEs
            dependent on these critical materials, particularly  from countries such as Australia, Canada and African
            Japan’s high-tech and automotive sectors, which rely  nations. Although these measures could reduce
            heavily  on  REEs  for  everything  from  smartphones  dependence on China in the long term, in the short


          14                                                                                           3-2025]]></page><page Index="15"><![CDATA[term such an embargo would likely cause significant  in the Salar de Uyuni, one of the largest salt flats in
            economic and geopolitical instability.            the  world.  These  communities  claim  that  lithium
                                                              mining will deplete local water reserves and damage
            Scenario 1: China imposes restrictions to REEs  the fragile ecosystems on which they depend. As
            exportse                                          competition for lithium intensifies, these protests
            Africa, with its vast reserves of cobalt,  lithium and  could  escalate  into  wider  conflicts,  attracting  the
            rare earth elements, is becoming an increasingly  attention of foreign powers with a vested interest in
            important battleground in the global competition for  securing access to the region’s resources.
            critical materials. China, the US and Europe all have a  Western nations and China, both of which rely on
            vested interest in securing access to these resources,  REEs for their electric vehicle industries, could find
            which are essential for the production of advanced  themselves indirectly involved in these conflicts,
            technologies  and  military  systems.  As  demand  for  either  through  their  investments  in  local  mining
            these  materials  continues  to  grow,  Africa  could  companies  or  through  diplomatic  efforts  to  protect
            become a flashpoint for military conflict or proxy  their access to critical materials. In the worst case,
            wars.                                             these environmental disputes could escalate into
            One  potential  flashpoint  is  again  the  Democratic  wider geopolitical conflicts as foreign powers seek to
            Republic of Congo, which holds more than half of the  influence local governments and secure preferential
            world’s cobalt reserves. As noted above, China has  access to lithium supplies. Resolving these conflicts
            already established a strong presence in the DRC’s  will require a careful balancing act between
            mining industry, securing long-term contracts and  environmental concerns, the rights of indigenous
            investing in infrastructure to facilitate the extraction  peoples and the growing global demand for critical
            and  export  of cobalt,  which has  raised  concerns  materials.
            among Western nations, particularly  the US, that
            China’s dominance of African resources could give  Scenario 4: Cyber warfare against rare earth
            it a strategic advantage in the global race for critical  supply chains
            materials.                                        In an increasingly digital and interconnected world,
            If tensions rise, the DRC and other resource-rich  control over REEs and critical raw materials extends
            African countries could become the scene of military  beyond the physical resources to the technologies
            intervention or proxy conflicts as foreign powers seek  and infrastructure that depend on them. As nations
            to protect their access to these vital materials. For  compete for access to these vital materials, cyber
            example, the United States could strengthen military  warfare could become an important tool for disrupting
            ties with African nations through security cooperation  rival supply chains or gaining access to proprietary
            agreements, providing training and equipment to  technologies for extracting or refining REEs.
            local  forces  in exchange  for preferential  access  to  In one possible scenario, a nation-state could launch
            critical  materials.  Alternatively,  regional  conflicts  a cyberattack on a rival’s rare earth processing
            could be fuelled by competition between Chinese  facilities. By targeting critical infrastructure, such as
            and Western-backed factions, further destabilising  computer  systems  that control mining  operations
            an already unstable region. Such conflicts would not  or refining processes, the attacker could disrupt the
            only have devastating humanitarian consequences,  rival’s supply chain and cause material shortages. This
            but could also disrupt global supply chains, causing  type of attack could have far-reaching consequences,
            shortages of critical materials and driving up prices.  affecting industries that rely on REEs, including
                                                              renewable energy, consumer electronics and military
            Scenario 3: Environmental conflicts and rights of  technologies.
            indigenous populations in Latin America           Such an attack could be particularly devastating if it
            The extraction  of lithium,  cobalt  and  other critical  targeted a country with limited domestic production
            materials often carries significant environmental  capacity, such as the United States or Japan, both of
            costs, and Latin America is at the forefront of these  which rely heavily on imports of REEs. In response,
            tensions. As global demand for lithium increases,  the targeted country could retaliate with its own
            driven by the transition to electric vehicles and  cyberattacks  or impose sanctions on the attacker,
            renewable energy technologies, the countries of the so-  risking an escalation of tensions and a wider conflict.
            called lithium triangle have become major suppliers.  Furthermore, the vulnerability of global supply chains
            However, mining activities in these countries have  to  cyberattacks  highlights  the  need  for  increased
            sparked conflicts with local indigenous communities  cybersecurity measures and resilience in the REEs
            concerned about environmental degradation and  sector. Countries that are able to protect their
            water scarcity caused by lithium mining.          critical infrastructure from cyber threats will have a
            In Bolivia, for example, indigenous groups have  significant advantage in the ongoing competition for
            protested against plans to expand lithium mining  REEs and critical materials.


            Informazioni della Difesa                                                                         15]]></page><page Index="16"><![CDATA[MITIGATING          FUTURE          CONFLICTS:    projects, promoting recycling initiatives and investing
            INTERNATIONAL          COOPERATION         AND    in alternative sources of REEs can reduce these
            INITIATIVES                                       vulnerabilities and ensure a more stable supply of
            While the potential for future conflicts over REEs  critical materials.
            and critical materials is significant, there are several  The first step towards diversification is the
            strategies that nations can pursue to mitigate these  development of new mining projects in previously
                Besides highlighting the forecasted EU demand in 2030 relative to current production, the figure shows that the
            risks and ensure a more stable and equitable  under-exploited regions. Countries such as Australia,       Access to raw materials and EU strategic partnerships
                ERMA cases identified to date can supply a very significant proportion of the EU demand. The values reported
            distribution of these vital resources.            Canada and African nations have significant reserves    In recent times, raw materials have forcefully come to the attention of the public and policymakers. There is now
                in Figure 2 are based on the current assumptions in terms of relative proportions of energy sources and battery
            One of the most effective strategies is to  diversify  of REEs and other critical raw materials, but these   an increased awareness of the risks associated with potential disruptions in the supply chains that underpin the
            global supply chains. Currently, REEs production and  resources have  not been fully exploited  due to a   EU’s economic prosperity, social stability and safety.
                types, as outlined in Figure 3. Figure 4 further shows that ERMA investments are distributed not only across Eu-
            refining is highly concentrated in a few key regions,  lack of investment or infrastructure. By working with
                rope and among different materials, but also, most importantly, across value chains. This is in line with ERMA’s
            particularly  China,  which  controls  a significant  these  nations  to  develop  mining  projects,  countries
                strategy to build up capacity and skills across all stages of the value chain, from exploration to mining, process-
            portion of the global market. This concentration                                                          While it is true that significant capacity exists within the EU, international partnerships need to be further de-
                ing, manufacturing and recycling. More investment cases will be submitted to ERMA in the coming months and
            of supply has created vulnerabilities for countries   currently reliant on Chinese imports can reduce     veloped to ensure diversification of supply and to address short-term as well as long-term gaps for some ma-
                years, potentially increasing the overall materials for energy storage and conversion production and recycling
            dependent  on  these  materials,  particularly  in  the  their dependence on a single supplier. For example,   terials. International partnerships need to be developed in harmony and synergy with the support provided by
                capacity in Europe across the various CRMs value chains.
            event of geopolitical tensions or trade disruptions.  Australia has become a major player in the global REEs   the EU and Member States to develop domestic resources. In this context, ERMA is multiplying its international
            Diversifying supply chains by developing new mining  market, with companies such as Lynas Corporation     strategic partnerships and outreach activities, both in terms of membership and in the leadership of investment
                                                                                                                      cases (Figure 5). In line with the European Commission’s outreach strategy, ERMA is a key player in the part-
                                                                                                  Graphite            nership with Canada and has been a driving force in the Memorandum of Understanding between the European
                                                                                                  LCE                 Union and Ukraine on a Strategic Partnership on Raw Materials. Other non-EU countries of strategic relevance
                                               NMC                                                Mn                  for ERMA include Kazakhstan and Namibia, and several countries with partnerships in the pipeline (Greenland
                  Battery Production                                                              Co
                                                                                                  Ni                  and Norway) or already announced (Argentina, Australia, Chile, Democratic Republic of Congo and Rwanda).
                                               NCA
                                                LFP                                                                   Besides its industry support for individual investment cases, ERMA is assisting the European Commission with
                                                                                                  Si                  the identification of emerging technologies and research topics that will restore the EU’s know-how and inno-
                                                                                                                      vation capacity. These include, among others, exploration, mining, processing, and recycling of materials used in
                  PV Solar Production
                                                                                                                      solar energy, wind energy and hydrogen-related technologies.

                                                                                                  Cu
                  Wind Generator Production
                                                                                                  Zn
                                                                                                  Cr
                                                                                                  REE
                 Figure 3. Link between technologies used for energy storage and conversion and raw materials needs, based on current assumptions regarding the energy mix and battery chemistries
                  (NMC - Nickel-Manganese-Cobalt; NCA - Nickel-Cobalt-Aluminium: and LFP - Lithium-Iron-Phosphate). The need of raw materials for the production of batteries will be affected
                                            significantly by the market share of specific battery chemistry mixes.
                                                                                                                                                               Greenland


                                                                    REFINING AND
                              EXPLORATION    MINING     PROCESSING  ADVANCED PRODUCTS  RECYCLING  % of 2030 EU demand                                      Norway                Kazakhstan
                Lithium and Boron                                                           40% Li and >100% B            Canada                               Ukraine
                Nickel and Cobalt                                                           ≈20% Ni and >40% Co
                     Graphite                                                               ≈20%
                   Rare Earths                                                              >40%
                                                                                                                                                               DRC          Rwanda
                    Vanadium                                                                40%
                                                                                                                                                             Namibia
                  Molybdenum                                                                20%                                                                                  Australia
                   Magnesium                                                                60%                                             Chile
                                                                                                                                                      Argentina
                     Tungsten                                                               60%
                      Others                                                                                                                Partnerships Signed  Partnerships in the pipeline  Partnerships Announced
                  (Ag, Cr, Cu, In, Nb,
                  P, PGE, Sb, Sc, Si,
                    Sn, Ta, Ti, Zn)
                         Figure 4. High-level view of the distribution of ERMA investment cases for a selected group of critical and strategic materials across the value chains.  Figure 5. Current and future EU-International strategic partnerships in the raw materials sector. Source: European Commission.
                                        The size of the bars is proportional to the investment needed for the various projects.
          16    16                                                                                     3-2025                                                                                               17]]></page><page Index="17"><![CDATA[NEW ROADMAP FOR A VALUE CHAIN ON RAW MATERIALS
                                                     ERMA 2023


 Lithium*                                     REE*
 2020  2030                 2020                               2030


 430,000  2,500,000  225,000
 800,000                                         315,000
 185,000        125,000                          18,800                                     Global and EU
 50,000                               10,000                                                demand
 Near Zero                            Near Zero                           >40%              and production
 40%                                                                                        data for 2020,
 * Lithium Carbonate Equivalent - LCE  *2030 EU demand and ERMA potential relate to REEs in permanent magnets.
                                                                                            compared
                                             Silicon*
 Nickel                                     Lithium*                                        with projected                   REE*
                            2020
                                                               2030
 2020  2030                 2020                              2030                          global and EU   2020                              2030
                                                                                            demand
                                                                                            for 2030
 2,510,000     3,218,000                       2,500,000
                430,000
                                                                                               225,000
 4,567,000                                      4,000,000                                   and potential                       315,000
 2,340,000     3,090,000                        800,000                                     supply from                         18,800
                185,000
                                                                                               125,000
                                                 600,000
                                      453,000
 296,000  1,290,000                  50,000                                                 projects                 10,000                              >40%
                                     Near Zero
                                                                                                                     Near Zero
                                                                                            identified
 50,079  ≈20%                         367,000                                               through
                                * Lithium Carbonate Equivalent - LCE
                            *Total production. Data reported are for EEA member countries.  40%  the ERMA  *2030 EU demand and ERMA potential relate to REEs in permanent magnets.
                                                                                            investment
                                             Copper
 Cobalt                                      Nickel                                         pipeline,                       Silicon*
 2020  2030                 2020                              2030                          for a selected   2020                             2030
                            2020
                                                               2030
                                                                                            group of critical
              23,500,000                                                                    and strategic
                                                                                              3,218,000
               2,510,000
 140,000                                         4,567,000                                  materials.                         4,000,000
                                                                                              3,090,000
               2,340,000
 129,110  269,000  20,680,000                  25,500,000                                   All figures are                     600,000
 31,000  60,525                      296,000   3,000,000                                                             453,000
                                                 1,290,000
                                      2,758,000
 1,559  >40%                         50,079                              ≈20%               expressed                367,000
                                                                                            in metric tons.
                                      871,800                             ≈15%                             *Total production. Data reported are for EEA member countries.
                                             Cobalt                                                                         Copper
 Graphite                   2020               Zinc           2030                                          2020                              2030
 2020  2030                 2020                               2030                         Source:
                                                                                            World Mining
                                                                                              23,500,000
                140,000
 947,000  ≈5,000,000  13,278,000                  269,000                                   Data and other                    25,500,000
                                                                                              20,680,000
                                                                                            EIT RawMaterials
                129,110
 940,000      13,100,000             31,000    18,100,000                                   internal and                      3,000,000
                                                   60,525
                                                2,589,000
                                      1,900,000
 79,000  ≈1,500,000                  1,559                               >40%               external sources.        2,758,000
 5,757                                770,000                             ≈20%                                       871,800                             ≈15%
 ≈20%
                                            Graphite                                                                         Zinc
 i
 G Global  l  G Global Mining     E Eu Demand d  E Eu Mining   E ERMA A  2020  2030                         2020                              2030
 g
 M
 l
 l
 M
 b

 l
 o
 a
 R
 i
 n
 b
 n
 u

 i
 M
 g
 a
 i
 n
 o
 n
 n
 a
 m
 u
 D

 e
 t
 n
 r
 D Demand d  P Production n  P Production n  P Potential l
 u
 c
 a
 m
 i
 c
 a
 i
 n
 t
 t
 o
 r
 i
 e
 o
 o
 t
 o
 d
 u
 e
 o
 d
 Global and EU demand and production data for 2020, compared to projected global and EU demand for 2030   947,000  ≈5,000,000  13,278,000
 and potential supply from projects identified through the ERMA investment pipeline, for a select group of critical   940,000  13,100,000  18,100,000
 and strategic materials. All figures are expressed in metric tonnes.  Fonte: World Mining Data and other EIT RawMaterials internal and external sources.  1,900,000  2,589,000
                                     79,000
                                     5,757   ≈1,500,000                                                              770,000                             ≈20%
                                                                         ≈20%
                                                             n
                                                             i
                                                                          M
                                                                          R
                                                            n

                                                          u
                                                            i
                                                           M
                                M
                 b

                G Global  l  G Global Mining     E Eu Demand d  E Eu Mining  g  E ERMA A
                l
                 o
                               a
                              b
                              o
                  a
                                l
                             l
                                  i
                                  n
                                   g
                                   n
                                 i
                                               D
                                                e
                                              u

                                                 m
                                                  a
                                                  n
                e
                                                                             i
                                                                            t
                                                                           e
                                                                           n
                   n
                D Demand d   P Production n              P Production n  P Potential l
                  a
                 m
                                                                             a
                             r
                                                           d
                                t
                                c
                                                            u
                                 i
                                 o
                                                           o
                                                          r
                                                             c
                              o
                              d
                                                                          t
                                                                          o
                               u
                                                             t
                                                              o
                                                              i
             Global and EU demand and production data for 2020, compared to projected global and EU demand for 2030
            Informazioni della Difesa                                                                         17
             and potential supply from projects identified through the ERMA investment pipeline, for a select group of critical
             and strategic materials. All figures are expressed in metric tonnes.                Fonte: World Mining Data and other EIT RawMaterials internal and external sources.]]></page><page Index="18"><![CDATA[producing  and refining REEs for  export to the US,  for example, have a 30% lower energy density
            Japan and other countries.  Increased investment in  than neodymium, limiting their use in high-end
            mining in Canada and African countries could further  applications. Furthermore, according to a report
            diversify global supply chains and reduce the risk of  by the International Energy Agency, scaling up
            supply disruptions.                               production will require infrastructure investment
            In addition to the development of new mining  and a full transition could take 10-15 years.
            projects,  recycling initiatives play a crucial role in  Diversifying the supply chain requires a multi-
            diversifying supply chains. Many of the products that  dimensional approach: technological innovation,
            rely on REEs, such as electric vehicles, wind turbines  international cooperation and supportive policies.
            and consumer electronics, have a limited lifespan, but  Countries such as the US and Australia are
            the materials they contain can often be recovered  increasing domestic production of REEs, but reducing
            and reused. By promoting the recycling of REEs  dependence will mainly come from alternative
            from end-of-life products, countries can reduce their  materials and circular models.
            dependence on primary imports and create a more  International cooperation is also essential to diversify
            sustainable supply of critical materials.         supply chains. Countries with significant reserves
            The EU has committed €2.1 billion to projects such as  of REEs and critical materials must work together
            RARE³, which recovers neodymium from hard drives  to ensure that these resources are developed and
            and  electric  motors  with  95%  efficiency.  Belgium’s  distributed in an equitable and sustainable manner.
            Umicore also recycles 200 tonnes per year of REEs  By forming strategic alliances and partnerships,
            from batteries and magnets.                       nations can share knowledge, resources and
            Another important aspect of diversifying the supply  technologies to create a more resilient global supply
            chain is exploring alternative materials to replace  chain. For example, the United States, the European
            REEs in key technologies. For example, an electric  Union and Australia have worked together to develop
            vehicle  motor  requires  about  1-2  kg  of  rare  earth  alternative sources of REEs and critical materials to
            magnets, while an offshore wind turbine uses up to  reduce their dependence on Chinese imports. These
            600 kg. Global demand for rare earth magnets could  partnerships have the added benefit of strengthening
            triple to 400,000 tonnes per year by 2030, but supply  diplomatic ties and promoting cooperation  in other
            is not keeping pace, with a projected shortfall of 30-  areas such as trade, defence and environmental
            40% for elements such as dysprosium.              protection.
            Research is therefore focusing on rare-earth-free  Ultimately,  diversifying  supply  chains  is  a  key
            magnets, as in the case of the US ARPA-E project, which  strategy for mitigating future conflicts over REEs and
            has funded the development of ferrite and manganese  critical materials. By developing new mining projects,
            alloy (MnAl-C) magnets with competitive performance  promoting recycling initiatives, exploring alternative
            at lower cost. The start-up company Niron Magnetics  materials and fostering international cooperation,
            has developed an iron nitride (FeN) magnet with an  nations can reduce their vulnerability and ensure
            energy density comparable to neodymium, which has  a more stable and equitable distribution of these
            already been tested by automotive companies. In the  vital  resources.  Although  the  path  to  diversification
            wind power sector, Siemens Gamesa has launched  requires significant investment and innovation, it
            turbines with electrically excited generators (without  offers the most sustainable solution to the growing
            permanent magnets), reducing the use of REEs by  competition for REEs and critical materials in the 21st
            100%.  An  example  of  this  technology  is  the  Kaskasi  century.
            offshore wind farm in Germany.
            Tesla  has  eliminated  REEs  from  the  motors  of  its  Recycling and sustainable mining practices offer
            “next-generation drive unit” by 2023, opting for ferrite  long-term solutions to the looming global shortage of
            magnets and induction systems (Tesla Master Plan  REEs and critical raw materials. As demand for these
            Part 3). Toyota is also experimenting with reluctance  materials continues to grow, particularly due to the
            synchronous motors combined with low-dysprosium  increasing adoption of renewable energy technologies
            magnets, reducing the use of REEs by 50 per cent.  and electric vehicles, it is becoming increasingly clear
            Another practical example of these research initiatives  that traditional mining alone will not be able to meet
            is hydrolysis to produce green hydrogen: platinum  global demand. By investing in recycling technologies
            catalysts can be replaced by nickel- and iron-based  and adopting more sustainable mining practices,
            materials. Researchers at MIT have developed a  nations can reduce the environmental impact of
            cobalt-manganese oxide electrode that reduces costs  resource  extraction  while  ensuring  a  steady  and
            by 70 per cent8. BASF has introduced platinum-free  reliable supply of critical materials.
            fuel cell catalysts using iron nanoparticles.     Recycling is a key component of any sustainable
            Despite   progress,  alternatives  often  require  strategy for REEs and critical materials. Many
            compromises in efficiency or cost. Ferrite magnets,  products that rely on these materials, such as electric


          18                                                                                           3-2025]]></page><page Index="19"><![CDATA[Strategic Projects for the l'UE                              or ecologically sensitive

                                                                                       areas where the impact
                                                                                       of resource extraction
            vehicle batteries, wind turbines and consumer  can  be particularly  damaging. In  particular,
            electronics, have relatively short life spans. However,  indigenous communities are often disproportionately
            the REEs and critical materials used in these products  affected by mining activities, as their water and land
            can often be recovered and reused. The REEs  resources  are  threatened  by  pollution  and  habitat
            recycling  process  involves  recovering  materials  destruction. To address these concerns, mining
            from discarded products, processing them to remove  companies must engage with local communities and
            impurities and returning them to the supply chain.  prioritise the protection of their rights and resources.
            This not  only reduces the  need for new  mining  This can include measures such as conducting
            projects, but also minimises the environmental impact  environmental impact assessments, implementing
            of resource extraction. By promoting the recycling of  water conservation techniques and restoring mined
            REEs from end-of-life products, countries can reduce  areas to restore ecosystems after mining has ceased.
            their dependence on primary imports and create a  Ultimately, recycling and sustainable mining practices
            more sustainable, circular economy.               are essential to ensure a stable and equitable supply of
            The European Union has taken a leading role in  REEs and critical materials in the future. By investing
            promoting the recycling of REEs and critical materials.  in technologies that enable the recovery and reuse of
            In 2020, it launched its Circular Economy Action Plan,  these materials from end-of-life products, countries
            which includes initiatives to increase the recycling of  can reduce their dependence on new mining projects
            REEs from  discarded electronic equipment,  electric  and minimise the environmental impact of resource
            vehicle batteries and renewable energy systems.  extraction. At the same time, by adopting more
            Japan has also been at the forefront of recycling  sustainable mining practices and protecting local
            efforts, investing in technologies to recover REEs  communities and ecosystems, countries can ensure
            from e-waste and other end-of-life products. These  that REEs and critical materials are extracted in a
            initiatives demonstrate the potential for recycling  responsible and ethical manner. These strategies are
            to play a key role in the future supply of REEs and  critical not only to ensuring a stable supply of REEs,
            critical materials.                               but also to protecting the environment and promoting
            Sustainable mining practices are another important  a more sustainable global economy.
            aspect of ensuring the long-term supply of REEs
            and critical materials. Traditional mining methods  Third,  international agreements and diplomacy
            often  have  significant  environmental  impacts,  play a critical role in mitigating the risks of future
            including habitat destruction, water contamination  conflicts over REEs and critical materials. As global
            and air pollution. In regions such as China, these  competition for these vital resources intensifies, it is
            environmental concerns have led to widespread  becoming increasingly clear that cooperation among
            protests and calls for stricter regulation. To  nations is essential to ensure a fair and equitable
            address  these challenges,  mining  companies  and  distribution  of materials,  to  prevent resource-based
            governments are increasingly focusing on adopting  conflicts, and to address the environmental and social
            more  sustainable  practices that  minimise  the  challenges associated with resource extraction. By
            environmental impact of resource extraction.      establishing international frameworks for the trade,
            One  example  of  sustainable  mining  practices  is  production and management of REEs and critical
            the development of technologies that reduce the  materials, the global community can promote stability
            amount of waste generated during the extraction  and reduce the likelihood of geopolitical tensions.
            and processing of REEs. This includes innovations in  One of the key challenges in the global REEs market
            extraction techniques such as the use of bioleaching,  is the concentration of supply in a few countries,
            which uses naturally occurring bacteria to extract  particularly  China.  China controls  a significant
            metals from ores in a more environmentally friendly  proportion of the world’s REEs production and
            way. In addition, the use of energy sources such as  refining capacity, giving it considerable influence
            solar and wind power can help reduce the carbon  over global supply chains. This dominance has led to
            footprint of rare earth mining. By adopting these  concerns about the potential for supply disruptions,
            and other sustainable practices, mining companies  particularly in the event of geopolitical tensions or
            can  minimise  the  environmental  impact  of  their  trade disputes. International agreements that promote
            operations while ensuring a steady supply of critical  fair and transparent access to REEs and critical
            materials.                                        materials are essential to reducing these risks. For
            Another important aspect of sustainable mining is  example, agreements that set guidelines for trade in
            the protection of local communities and ecosystems.  REEs, including restrictions on export bans or tariffs,
            In many cases, mining activities take place in remote  can help ensure that all countries have access to the


            Informazioni della Difesa                                                                         19]]></page><page Index="20"><![CDATA[materials they need to support their industries and  associated with significant environmental costs. To
            economies.                                        address these challenges, nations must work together
            The World Trade Organisation (WTO) has already  to develop and implement international standards
            played a role in regulating trade in REEs and critical  for sustainable mining. Agreements that promote
            materials. In 2014, the WTO ruled against China’s  cleaner mining techniques, minimise environmental
            restrictions  on  rare  earth exports,  finding that  such  degradation and ensure responsible management of
            measures  violated  international  trade  agreements.  natural resources can help reduce the environmental
            The ruling was an important step in ensuring that  impact of REEs mining. For example, international
            countries cannot  use restrictions on rare earth  environmental agreements such as the Paris
            exports as a tool to gain geopolitical advantage. This  Agreement can encourage countries to adopt greener
            precedent underlines the importance of international  mining practices and reduce the carbon footprint
            trade institutions in maintaining fair access to critical  associated with the extraction of critical materials.
            materials. By establishing clear rules for REEs trade  Another key area where international diplomacy can
            and resolving disputes through diplomatic channels,  play a role is in protecting the rights of indigenous
            international organisations can help prevent conflicts  communities  and  local populations  affected  by
            that could result from supply disruptions or resource  mining activities. Many of the regions where REEs and
            nationalism.                                      critical materials are found are home to communities
            In addition to trade rules, international agreements  with long-standing cultural and economic ties
            focusing on sustainable mining practices and  to the territory in which they are located. The
            environmental protection are also crucial. As noted  expansion  of  mining  activities  often  poses a  threat
            above,  the  mining  and  processing  of  REEs  is  often  to these communities, leading to conflicts over land


          20                                                                                           3-2025]]></page><page Index="21"><![CDATA[those promoted by ERMA, can facilitate the sharing
                                                              of knowledge and expertise on sustainable mining
                                                              practices, resource management and supply chain
                                                              logistics.  These  partnerships  can  also  promote  the
                                                              development of local industries and create economic
                                                              opportunities  for  resource-rich  countries,  reducing
                                                              their dependence  on foreign  investment  and
                                                              promoting more sustainable economic growth.
                                                              In addition to bilateral and multilateral agreements,
                                                              international fora such as the United Nations (UN),
                                                              the G20 and the International Energy Agency
                                                              (IEA) provide platforms for dialogue on the global
                                                              management of REEs and critical materials. These
                                                              forums allow nations to share best practices, discuss
                                                              emerging challenges and coordinate efforts to
                                                              ensure a stable and sustainable supply of these
                                                              vital resources. By engaging in diplomacy through
                                                              these international institutions, countries can work
                                                              together to address global challenges related to REEs,
                                                              including supply chain vulnerabilities, environmental
                                                              degradation and resource-related conflicts.
                                                              Ultimately, international agreements and diplomacy
                                                              are essential to mitigate the risks of future conflicts
                                                              over REEs and critical commodities. By establishing
                                                              fair trade practices, promoting sustainable mining,
                                                              protecting the rights of indigenous communities
                                                              and fostering international cooperation, nations can
                                                              ensure a more stable and equitable distribution of
                                                              these vital resources. In doing so, they can reduce the
                                                              likelihood of resource-based conflicts and promote a
                                                              more sustainable and peaceful global economy.

                                                              In addition,  military diplomacy plays a crucial
                                                              role in shaping the geopolitical landscape  around
                                                              REEs and critical commodities, particularly as
                                                              competition for these resources intensifies. As nations
            rights, water use and environmental protection.  increasingly  recognise  the strategic  importance  of
            International agreements that recognise and protect  defence technologies, military diplomacy offers a way
            the rights of indigenous peoples are essential to  to manage tensions, secure access to resources and
            ensure that resource extraction does not occur  prevent conflict.
            at the expense of vulnerable populations. For  A key function of military diplomacy in this context is
            example, the United Nations Declaration on the  to promote alliances that secure critical materials for
            Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) provides a  the defence industry. Through military partnerships,
            framework for protecting the rights of indigenous  security agreements and joint exercises, nations can
            peoples in the context of resource development. By  strengthen ties with resource-rich countries and gain
            incorporating  UNDRIP  principles  into  international  access to critical raw materials in exchange for military
            mining agreements, countries can help safeguard the  assistance or defence cooperation. For example, the
            rights of indigenous communities and promote more  US and Australia have strengthened their military
            equitable resource management.                    and diplomatic ties, resulting in increased access to
            Countries with significant reserves of REEs and critical  Australia’s REEs. Similarly, military cooperation with
            materials often face economic and political challenges  African countries such as the Democratic Republic
            that make it difficult for them to take full advantage of  of Congo can help secure the cobalt  needed for
            their resource wealth. International cooperation can  advanced military technologies while ensuring the
            help address these challenges by providing technical  stability and security of mining operations.
            assistance, investing in infrastructure and supporting  In addition, military diplomacy can help protect
            capacity building in resource-rich countries. For  critical infrastructure that produces and refines REEs.
            example,  partnerships  between  nations,  such as  Working  with  allied nations,  the military  can  help


            Informazioni della Difesa                                                                         21]]></page><page Index="22"><![CDATA[defend mines, refineries and transport routes that are  and nickel, materials that are increasingly in demand
            critical to the global supply chain. This cooperation  and concentrated in certain regions. To address this
            can prevent disruptions caused by terrorist attacks,  challenge,  researchers  are  developing  alternative
            piracy  or  regional  instability,  ensuring  a  steady  battery chemistries that can reduce or eliminate
            flow of  materials  needed  for  military  production.  In  the need for these critical materials. For example,
            areas prone to instability, such as parts of Africa or  solid-state  batteries,  which use  a solid  rather  than
            Latin America, military presence and cooperation  liquid electrolyte, offer higher energy density and
            agreements can secure these goods, protecting both  greater safety than conventional lithium-ion batteries,
            the  security  of  the host  nation  and  the  interests  of  while reducing reliance on cobalt and other critical
            international stakeholders.                       materials.  Similarly,  researchers  are exploring  the
            In conclusion, military diplomacy is crucial to  potential of lithium-sulphur and sodium-ion batteries
            securing access to essential raw materials, preventing  as alternatives to lithium-ion technology.
            resource-based conflicts and safeguarding supply  Another  promising  area  of  innovation  is  the
            chains.  As  REEs and  critical  materials  continue  to  development  of  energy-efficient  technologies.
            underpin advanced military technologies, the role of  Advances in electric motor design could reduce the
            military diplomacy in maintaining global stability will  amount of REEs needed to produce high-performance
            become increasingly important.
            One of the most promising strategies for mitigating
            future conflicts over REEs and critical materials is to
            invest in alternative technologies that can reduce
            or eliminate the need for these materials. As global
            demand  for  REEs continues  to grow,  particularly  in
            sectors  such  as  renewable  energy,  electric  vehicles
            and high-tech manufacturing, there is growing interest
            in developing technologies that can replace REEs or
            use them more efficiently. By investing in research
            and development of alternative materials and
            technologies, countries can reduce their dependence
            on REEs and mitigate the risks associated with supply
            chain disruptions, resource scarcity and geopolitical
            tensions.
            One area of active research is the development of
            alternative magnets that do not rely on rare earth
            elements, such as neodymium or dysprosium.
            Researchers  are  exploring  the  use  of  alternative
            materials, such as iron- or cobalt-based magnets,
            which could replace rare earth-based magnets in
            some applications.
            In addition  to  alternative  magnetic  technologies,
            advances in materials science are opening up new
            possibilities. For example, scientists have long been
            exploring  the  use of  graphene  and  other  advanced
            materials in electronic devices, which could potentially
            replace REEs in some components. Graphene, a form
            of carbon arranged in a two-dimensional lattice,
            has exceptional electrical,  thermal and mechanical
            properties, making it a promising candidate for a
            wide range of applications. By harnessing its potential,
            researchers hope to develop new technologies that
            can reduce the need for REEs while maintaining or
            improving performance.
            Battery  technology  is  another  critical  area  where  motors used in electric vehicles and industrial
            investment in alternative technologies could help  machinery.
            reduce dependence on REEs and critical raw  Investment in alternative technologies is not limited
            materials. Lithium-ion batteries, widely used in  to the private sector; governments also play a crucial
            electric vehicles and renewable energy storage  role in supporting research and development efforts
            systems, require large quantities of lithium, cobalt  through funding and policy initiatives. In the US, for


          22                                                                                           3-2025]]></page><page Index="23"><![CDATA[example, the Department of Energy (DoE) has launched   of best practices for sustainable extraction and
            several initiatives to support the development of    processing.
            alternative  materials  and technologies  to  reduce
            reliance on REEs. One of the key programmes is the  The DoE is also funding the aforementioned research
            2021 Critical Materials Strategy, which covers a  into alternative magnetic technologies based on
            period up to 2031 and focuses on four key objectives  iron or cobalt for use in electric vehicles and wind
            for the energy and defence sectors, namely:       turbines. It is also supporting the development of
            •   Fostering scientific innovation and developing  solid-state and sodium-ion batteries. These efforts
                technologies that ensure resilient and secure  will  help  reduce  Europe’s  dependence  on  imports,
                mineral  and critical  materials  supply  chains,  particularly from China, and ensure more sustainable
                independent  of  extraction  and processing  by  supply chains for critical materials.
                foreign adversaries.                          In conclusion, investment in alternative technologies
            •   Catalysing  and support  private  sector adoption  is  a  key  strategy  to  mitigate  the  risks  associated
                and capacity for sustainable domestic supply  with  global  competition  for  REEs  and critical  raw
                chains of minerals and critical materials.    materials. By developing new materials, improving
            •   Building a long-term minerals and materials  the efficiency of existing technologies and reducing




















































                innovation ecosystem that fosters new capabilities  dependence on scarce resources, countries can
                to mitigate future critical minerals and materials  reduce their vulnerability to supply chain disruptions
                supply chain challenges.                      and geopolitical tensions. In doing so, they can
            •   Coordinating with international partners and  promote a more sustainable and resilient global
                allies and other federal agencies to diversify  economy  while  addressing  the environmental  and
                global supply chains and ensure the adoption  social challenges associated with resource extraction.


            Informazioni della Difesa                                                                         23]]></page><page Index="24"><![CDATA[CONCLUSIONS                                       instrumental in resolving trade disputes related to
            The growing importance of REEs and essential  REEs, and its role could be expanded to address
            commodities in civil and military technologies has  future challenges. Similarly, diplomatic efforts to
            transformed  these  resources  into strategic  assets  promote partnerships with resource-rich countries
            with the potential to reshape global power dynamics.  can help diversify global supply chains and reduce
            As nations become increasingly dependent on  vulnerabilities associated with dependence on a
            these  materials  for  the  production  of  renewable  single supplier.
            energy systems, electric vehicles and advanced  In addition to diplomatic efforts, investment in
            military  technologies,  competition  for access  to  alternative technologies offers a promising solution.
            these  resources  has  intensified.  The  potential  for  Research and development into materials that
            resource-based conflict, whether through trade wars,  can replace REEs in key technologies, such as
            military intervention or environmental disputes, has  alternative magnets for electric vehicles, can reduce
            increased as countries scramble to secure stable  global dependence on these critical resources.
            supplies. Nations that control access to REEs and  Examples  include projects  to  develop alternatives
            critical materials can gain significant technological  to REEs in  electric motors,  or the development
            and  military  advantages,  while  those  that  remain  of alternative battery technologies that use fewer
            dependent on imports face increased vulnerability.  critical materials, providing a sustainable path
            As demand for REEs continues to grow, particularly  for industries dependent  on lithium and cobalt.
            in the context of the global shift towards renewable  Recycling and sustainable mining practices are
            energy  and  advanced  technologies,  the  risk  of  also essential to address the threat of resource
            geopolitical conflict increases. Resource nationalism,  scarcity. Countries such as Japan and members of
            trade restrictions and the militarisation of resource-  the European Union are pioneering the development
            rich regions are some of the key threats that could  of technologies to recycle REEs from end-of-life
            disrupt  global  supply  chains.  For  example,  China’s  products, reducing the need for new mining projects
            near monopoly in REEs production and refining has  and minimising environmental impact. By creating a
            already created significant dependencies, prompting  circular economy around these materials, nations can
            other nations to seek alternative sources and reduce  reduce their environmental footprint while ensuring
            their reliance  on Chinese  exports. The US,  EU and  a steady supply of critical resources for the future.
            other countries have recognised the strategic risks
            associated with this dependence and are taking steps  In  conclusion,  the  future  of  REEs  and  critical  raw
            to diversify their supply chains, but progress remains  materials will be determined by the ability of nations
            slow.                                             to meet the challenges of competition for resources
            There are, however, sound strategies for reducing  and to seize the opportunities offered by technological
            the risks of resource-based conflicts and ensuring  innovation and international cooperation. Through
            a more stable and equitable distribution of critical  diversification, investment in alternatives and
            materials. International cooperation plays a key role  diplomatic engagement, it may be possible to reduce
            in these efforts, as nations work together to ensure  the risks of resource-based conflicts and ensure a
            access to REEs while promoting fair trade practices.  more stable, sustainable and equitable distribution of
            For example, the World Trade Organisation has been  these vital resources.





























          24                                                                                           3-2025]]></page></pages></Search>